How to Evaluate a Brand Designer Portfolio: A 15-Minute Test

How to evaluate a brand designer portfolio in 15 minutes: five timed checks, the red flags that actually matter and a scoresheet to compare designers.

FAQ

How do I evaluate a brand designer’s portfolio?

Run five checks of about three minutes each: confirm the brands are real and live, look for full systems on client-specific touchpoints, test one mark at small size and in one color, read one case study for the reasoning, and compare three projects for range.

What should a good brand designer portfolio include?

Case studies for real, live clients that show the whole identity system (logo family, color roles, type and imagery) on the client’s own touchpoints, small-size and one-color versions of the mark, and a short explanation of the brief and the decisions.

What are red flags in a brand designer’s portfolio?

No project traceable to a real company, every project ending at a logo on stock mockups with no real applications, no small-size or one-color versions, one look across every industry, generated imagery, and work that appears elsewhere under another name.

Does a designer need experience in my industry?

It helps but isn’t essential. Range across industries, each with a distinct look, shows the designer builds from the brief. Work in a close category is a bonus.

How many portfolios should I review?

Five to ten is usually enough to shortlist two or three for a call. Use the same scoring sheet for each so the comparison is fair.

What should I ask after reviewing the portfolio?

Ask the designer to walk through their strongest and weakest project, explain one decision they would change, and confirm who will do the work, what is included and when you own the files.

Sources

  1. Google: Search what you see with Lens
  2. Google Search Central: Define a favicon to show in search results
  3. Kamali et al.: How to Distinguish AI-Generated Images from Authentic Photographs (arXiv, 2024)
Masuder Rahaman, brand designer

Written by Masuder Rahaman

Brand designer helping founders in the US, the UK and the Middle East build brand identities, logos and guidelines. 8+ years of design, 350+ projects in 50+ countries.

One branding guide a month,
straight to your inbox.

Practical notes on brand identity, logos and rebrands for founders. Unsubscribe anytime.

Book a free call

Step 1 of 2